Thursday, February 12, 2015

Blog 3

Mark Samet
BLST 14
Wed 5PM
Blog 3
12 Feb 2015
The Swing Era
            The rise of jazz’s popularity continued to rise through the 1920s and into the 1930s with no sign of letting up. As jazz began to involve into the swing style that defined the 1930s, this style further catered to wider audiences and musicians, with a greater white presence in performing jazz, as well as an even larger white audience. With the advancement of radio and recording technologies, jazz had become a real, modern style pop culture entity. Similarly, as Professor Stewart had mentioned several times in lecture, racial tensions tend to increase during economic downturns, which may have been a factor in why race was explicitly written and talked about during the Swing Era.      
            Because of the increase presence of white performers during the Swing Era, this gave clubs the option to hire white bands to perform instead of black ones, the preferable option during the Jim Crow era. This put the black bands at risk, and was a cause of the tension, particularly during the Great Depression, where it would become tough to survive if the Black bands lost their gigs. According to Swing Changes, it says, “the conditions and prospects faced by African-American and white big bands had never been equivalent, and as swing became profitable business the disparity between the two groups increased” (page 122). Because of the popularity and demand for swing, more and more white performers were creating swing music, and had a far easier time performing in their venue of choice. With more white performers, there was greater competition between white and black artists, making it even more difficult for black artists to succeed.

            Because Swing had become the pop music of the 1930s, its popularity was bound to draw critics, who wrote about swing with clear racial biases towards black and white performers. In Swing Changes, it is noted that the reviews of jazz went deeper than just a simple positive or negative view, the way it had been in the 1920s. In the 1930s, Swing Changes says, “writers who criticized and reviewed jazz sought to define a political meaning for the music” (page 53). One notable writer, John Hammond, straddled the racial divide, endorsing and support both Black and White artists. He supported both the white Benny Goodman, as well as black artists like Fletcher Henderson, Count Basie, and Billie Holiday. His support of both black and white artists (though he did say black bands were inherently better than white bands) is representative of the overall theme of the Swing era. Though there was a definitely segregation and tension between the white and black artists, realistically they couldn’t survive without the support from each other. Down Beat said, “Jazz, black and white, and democracy go hand in hand. One cannot exist while the other is suppressed” (page 73).  Although there was a known discrepancy between white and black bands, without the support of the white audience, and without the influence from the original black jazz bands, Swing would not have become the defining pop culture icon of the 1930s.

3 comments:

  1. I enjoyed your citings from the text and the excerpt from Down Beat. Your blog post describes in depth the racial tensions yet their inability to function without each other. The two sided argument is very convincing and your historical evidence definitely backs your thesis. Do you believe this musical racism disappeared after the swing era? Do you believe in modern society there are places where certain races are still slightly discouraged from playing?

    ReplyDelete
  2. I like that you mention how hiring white bands over black bands was preferred due to the issues of race and segregation still prevalent in society as they could prevent the band from performing or from being treated with respect. I especially like the quote that emphasizes the "disparity" between the two groups. I agree with your point that neither band could survive without each other because whites helped make jazz mainstream and gather an audience for black jazz musicians, and the black artists inspired many white jazz musicians when writing their music.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Great post. I like how you brought up how black bands lost opportunities in the Swing Era leading to tension. How much do you think the rise of the radio played a role in giving white musicians more opportunities? Also why do you think that the racial tension was not more prevalent before the Swing Era?

    ReplyDelete