Mark Samet
BLST 14
TA: George Blake, 6PM
Blog 4
5 March 2015
Blog 4
According
to Thelonious Monk’s biography by Robin D.G. Kelley, San Juan Hill was a
culturally diverse community, with Irish, Germans, and Italians living on the
avenues, while the cross streets were generally all Black, with “most of them
coming from the South or the Caribbean” (page 18). This was a tight-knit group
of people, with “the Black residents developing a strong sense of community”
(page 20). Kelley said that in this community, it seemed as though every house
had an instrument, so Monk was always surrounded by music, and he lived near
some prominent musicians, like local jazz musician Alberta Simmons, who was a
major influence for Monk and his playing. Kelley refers to San Juan Hill’s
Columbus Hill Neighborhood Center as another influence in Monk’s development as
a musician (page 28). The Center was key in making the children of the
community feel important, and for Thelonious, it further fostered his
musicianship since he played the piano in the music program. Being surrounded
by a positive, tight-knit community where music happened to proliferate deeply
among the people must have fostered Monk’s “genius”, the avant-garde style jazz
musician that he would become. Though he was faced with prejudice and
competition with White peers, he grew up in a community that fostered jazz where
everyone knew everyone and encouraged him to do what he pleased, which may have
been what gave him the courage to continue his love of this piano to play jazz.
The statement “Jazz is New York, man!” may mean that the community aspect of the
neighborhood was a major influence in jazz, so jazz was an embodiment of New
York City in that sense.
The
relationship between jazz and the community in Leimert Park is similar to that
in San Juan Hill in terms of its integration into the community, however I think
that in Leimert Park, jazz brought the community together, whereas in San Juan
Hill brought jazz together. The tight community of San Juan Hill encouraged the
jazz to flourish among the people living there, because they were all playing
music previously. However, the video said that Leimert Park had begun evolving
into an artistic hub for African Americans in LA, but when 5th
Street Dicks coffee shop opened, they placed chairs outside on the sidewalk,
drawing loads of people from the community when jazz was played inside of the
coffee shop. I think this may have been the function of jazz having a different
role in pop culture in the 1930s versus the 1990s and 2000s, where jazz was now
in the background of musical production, rather than the foreground, so it was
much less commonly played by musicians than in the 1930s.
Though the
relationship to the communities may have been different in San Juan Hill and Leimert
Park, both exemplify how art can both help unite a community, and also how a
community can lead to the creation of unique art.
Sources
Kelley, R. (2009). Thelonious Monk: The Life and Times of an
American Original. New York: Simon & Schuster, Inc.
Toney, A. A Coffee Company Called 5th Street Dick’s. KCET, 11
Apr. 2011
Commented on Erisy Watt
I agree with your point that the environment in San Juan Hill encouraged Monk's passion for music. If he hadn't been surrounded by musicians growing up, who knows if he would have discovered that he wanted to be one, too. There was that section in the biography about him spending his childhood summers at a fire station in the country--what if he had become fire fighter instead of musician? A part of jazz's legacy might have been missing.
ReplyDeleteYour analysis of the parallels between San Juan Hill and Leimert Park seems to be particularly perceptive. I like how you include a logical, yet concise list of similarities and differences between the two cities.
ReplyDeleteI think you make a really good comparison between San Juan Hill and Leimert Park in saying that San Juan Hill as a location brought people like Thelonious Monk into the jazz world, whereas in Leimert Park, jazz was the catalyst that brought the people together. I definitely agree with your point that jazz could not have existed without the community, and vice versa, the community could not have existed without jazz. I like your analysis on both Thelonious Monk's relation to jazz through his upbringing, as well as the connection between jazz and the community of Leimert Park. Great work!
ReplyDeleteI enjoyed reading your post, and I agree that a community can both be united under a unique art form, or it can create its own unique art form. However, I also think that both can occur in the same location, that is, a unique art form can develop in a location as a result of the unique influences from a different art form.
ReplyDelete